Kevin Seifert: I agree with it in the abstract. Mike Greenberg said, "I will tell you the one place they have to play the Super Bowl and that's Lambeau Field." Do you agree or disagree with that statement? Brett of Milwaukee writes: I know you addressed this earlier, but how can you not consider Lambeau Field as a possible Super Bowl destination? It is the most historic field in the NFL, and the vote for New Jersey wipes away any indication that weather will play a factor in the future. It's a valuable, but not all-encompassing, statistic.įor those who are interested in more information, Football Outsiders will evaluate every NFL player's broken tackles in their annual yearbook, due out in early July. It was a specific analysis of how many times he allowed someone to run around or through him when he should have made the tackle. This wasn't an evaluation of the ground a player can cover or his total impact on a game. We try to never judge intent when we mark stats in game charting." Only the player and the coaches truly know that. Here's how Schatz put it: "We don't know a player's responsibilities on a play. I reached out to Football Outsiders president Aaron Schartz, who pointed out the dangers of trying to reward players who made plays out of position and penalize those who couldn't get to the point of attack. This can be problematic, but I'm not sure there is a solution that would help us evaluate it further. If a player is really quick and gets into position to make tackles that others wouldn't, should we penalize him for missing some of them? Are we, in effect, rewarding the shortstop who is too slow to get his glove on the ball? I probably should have specified game totals to help provide some context.īut Andrew is mostly asking about players' opportunities to make or miss tackles based on positioning. That means Levy was missing tackles at a greater per-game rate than Briggs. But Briggs started 15 games last season, while Levy started 10. First, the Chicago Bears' Lance Briggs is at the top of the list, tied with the Detroit Lions' DeAndre Levy with 12 missed tackles. When you look at our list of the 10 NFC North players against whom the most tackles were broken, you see a level of disparity in several aspects. There is a subjective element in whether a guy who rushes to the point of attack from the backside really had time to breakdown, and whether a missed tackle should be awarded, but beyond that it would be useful to know at what rate the players are having their tackles broken. It also reminds me of the issue with using errors in baseball - it punishes players for getting in position to make a play, while failing to account for the player who reacted so slowly/poorly that he wasn't close enough to have the chance to make a play. Simply looking at defensive snaps doesn't do it, because that doesn't take into account a player's opportunities. However, it's a more complicated question for defenders. Let's all ride with Private Malone this weekend.Ĭomplaints/suggestions/communiqués through the mailbag, Facebook and Twitter.Īndrew of Calgary was one of many readers who asked for further context on our broken tackles post: Do Football Outsiders qualify the broken tackles by number of opportunities? For offensive players, it is simply a matter of looking at touches, and I have a rough idea of the number of touches that the listed players have. You'll always be riding with Private Malone Though you may take her and make her your own (Normally you have to listen to a country song backwards for something good to happen.) The tune is " Riding with Private Andrew Malone" and tells the story of a guy who finds a letter from a previous owner of the car he just bought.Īnd if your readin' this, then I didn't make it home Remember why you have the opportunity to enjoy it.Ĭall me a sap, but the song that's popping in my head is actually a rare, uplifting country tune from David Ball. I have two requests for this holiday weekend:
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |